|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Journal of Lipid Research, Vol. 46, 2102-2113, October 2005 Gaucher disease mouse models: point mutations at the acid ß-glucosidase locus combined with low-level prosaposin expression lead to disease variants
* Division and Program in Human Genetics, Children's Hospital Research Foundation, Cincinnati, OH 45229-3039 Published, JLR Papers in Press, August 1, 2005. DOI 10.1194/jlr.M500202-JLR200
1 To whom correspondence should be addressed. e-mail: greg.grabowski{at}cchmc.org
Gaucher disease is a common lysosomal storage disease caused by a defect of acid ß-glucosidase (GCase). The optimal in vitro hydrolase activity of GCase requires saposin C, an activator protein that derives from a precursor, prosaposin. To develop additional models of Gaucher disease and to test in vivo effects of saposin deficiencies, mice expressing low levels (445% of wild type) of prosaposin and saposins (PS-NA) were backcrossed into mice with specific point mutations (V394L/V394L or D409H/D409H) of GCase. The resultant mice were designated 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA, respectively. In contrast to PS-NA mice, the 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice displayed large numbers of engorged macrophages and nearly exclusive glucosylceramide (GC) accumulation in the liver, lung, spleen, thymus, and brain. Electron microscopy of the storage cells showed the characteristic tubular storage material of Gaucher cells. Compared with V394L/V394L mice, 4L/PS-NA mice that expressed 46% of wild-type prosaposin levels had 2575% decreases in GCase activity and protein in liver, spleen, and fibroblasts. These results imply that reduced saposin levels increased the instability of V394L or D409H GCases and that these additional decreases led to large accumulations of GC in all tissues. These models mimic a more severe Gaucher disease phenotype and could be useful for therapeutic intervention studies.
Abbreviations: CNS, central nervous system; gba, gene encoding mouse acid ß-glucosidase; GC, glucosylceramide; GCase, acid ß-glucosidase; LacCer, lactosylceramide; 4MU-Glc, 4-methylumbelliferyl-ß-D-glucopyranoside; WT, wild-type Supplementary key words macrophage lysosomal storage disease glycosphingolipids
Gaucher disease is an autosomal recessive trait and the most common lysosomal storage disorder (1). The defective lysosomal hydrolysis of glucosylceramide (GC) in Gaucher disease is caused by mutations in the gene [human (GBA), mouse (gba)] encoding acid ß-glucosidase (GCase), a membrane-associated lysosomal hydrolase (1). More than 200 mutations at the GBA locus have been identified in Gaucher disease patients, and the resultant defective or deficient enzyme activities lead to variable phenotypes (1, 2). The accumulation of GC leads to enlargement of the liver and spleen, bone lesions, and central nervous system (CNS) manifestations in some variants (1, 35). The macrophage is the primary cell displaying GC accumulation; nonmacrophage parenchymal cells appear normal in liver, lung, bone marrow, and spleen in Gaucher disease (e.g., hepatocytes, granulocytes, and lymphocytes) (1). The knock out of gba in the mouse leads to lethality in the newborn period (6). Efforts to create animal models of Gaucher disease with a longer life span have included the gba "knock in" of the L444P mutation, but this also led to early death attributable, at least in part, to a defective skin permeability barrier (7).
Additional mouse models were designed based on genotype/phenotype correlations in humans (8), as summarized in Table 1. Homozygosity for N370S in humans results in less severe to asymptomatic phenotypes (1, 9, 10). In comparison, homozygosity for the D409H allele is associated with early-onset, variable disease of the viscera and CNS (11, 12). These patients also can develop characteristic calcific abnormalities of the aortic valves and ascending aorta (13). The V394L allele has been observed only in the heteroallelic state, and when the heteroallele is L444P, the phenotype includes visceral and CNS involvement (11). In contrast, N370S homozygosity in mice was lethal in the neonatal period, V394L homozygosity displayed minor phenotypic abnormalities up to 12 months, and D409H or D409V homozygotes displayed low-grade Gaucher cell formation and GC storage (8). Visceral tissues from homozygous murine models of V394L and D409H showed
Saposins (sphingolipid activator proteins) A, B, C, and D are lysosomal glycoproteins that are encoded by a single gene, termed prosaposin (1417). The saposins are essential to the optimal activity of glycosphingolipid hydrolases (1821). In particular, saposin C is needed for full GCase function (2224). Saposin C has at least two effects on GCase: 1) optimization of GCase hydrolysis of GC and other substrates; and 2) a protective effect for GCase against proteolytic digestion (24). This latter finding probably accounts for the reduction of GCase activity and protein levels in prosaposin-deficient mice and humans (24). In humans, deficiency of saposin C leads to a variant form of Gaucher disease with GC accumulation in macrophages and CNS (25). The proteolytic processing of prosaposin to the individual saposins occurs predominantly in acidified compartments, including the lysosome (26, 27). Prosaposin has been found in a variety of body fluids (14, 28). To establish additional viable Gaucher disease mouse models and evaluate the in vivo effect of saposin C on mutant GCases, mice were created by cross-breeding V394L or D409H homozygotes into the PS-NA line that expresses subnormal levels of a transgene encoding mouse prosaposin/saposins. The resulting mice developed large accumulations of GC in a variety of tissues as a more florid viable analog of human Gaucher disease with CNS involvement.
Materials The following were from commercial sources: 4-methylumbelliferyl-ß-D-glucopyranoside (4MU-Glc; Biosynth AG); sodium taurocholate (Calbiochem, La Jolla, CA); mouse anti-ß-actin monoclonal antibody, trypsin, trypsin inhibitor, and primulin (Sigma, St. Louis, MO); NuPAGE 412% Bis-Tris gel, NuPAGE MES SDS running buffer, William's solution, collagenase, Ca/Mg-free HBSS, DMEM, neurobasal medium, and B27 supplement (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA); rat anti-mouse CD68 monoclonal antibody (Serotec, Oxford, UK); M-PER Mammalian Protein Extraction Reagent and BCA Protein Assay Reagent (Pierce, Rockford, IL); [35S]cysteine/methionine protein labeling mix (DuPont-New England Nuclear Research Products, Boston, MA); Molecular Dynamics Storm 860 scanner, HybondTM-ECLTM nitrocellulose membrane, and ECL detection reagent (Amersham Biosciences, Piscataway, NJ); ABC Vectastain and Alkaline Phosphatase Kit II (black) (Vector Laboratory, Burlingame, CA); and BD TALONTM Metal Affinity Resin (BD Biosciences Clontech, Palo Alto, CA).
Mouse models
PCR genotyping
Histological studies
Tissue lipid analyses
Enzyme activity assay
Preparation of anti-mouse prosaposin antiserum
Cell culture and immunoprecipitation Hepatocytes were isolated from liver after perfusion with collagenase solution (0.2 mg/ml collagenase and 0.33 mM CaCl2 in HBSS). Liver tissues were minced into small pieces with scissors and suspended in William's solution. The liver suspension was washed twice with William's solution, layered over the Percoll, and centrifuged (2 min at 800 g). The resultant pellets were washed twice in William's solution, and hepatocytes were plated in DMEM with 10% fetal bovine serum and 1% glutamine as well as penicillin and streptomycin in a 10 cm dish. The fresh medium was replaced after 1 h. The hepatocytes were allowed to grow for 7 days and then subjected to labeling and immunoprecipitation. Mouse lung or tail fibroblasts were cultured in DMEM supplemented with 10% heat-activated fetal bovine serum as described previously (38). The above cells (510 x 105 cells per flask) were labeled for 4 h with 127 µCi of [35S]cysteine/methionine protein labeling mix. The media were collected and treated with anti-mouse saposin D antibody to precipitate the prosaposin protein. The proteins were resolved by SDS-PAGE as described (31).
Immunoblot
Creation of mouse models To investigate the effect of saposins on GCase in vivo, the mouse models were generated by cross-breeding GCase point mutant (V394L or D409H) mice with prosaposin knockout (PS/) mice or a hypomorphic prosaposin mouse line [i.e., PS/ with a low-expressing mouse prosaposin transgene (PS-NA)] (Table 2). Both GCase mutant (V394L or D409H) mice were fertile and lived up to 2 years (8). The respective resultant cross-bred mice were designated 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA; these mice were fertile and survived up to 22 weeks. The PS-NA mice were fertile, with life spans up to 32 weeks (31). The PS/ mice (i.e., prosaposin-null) generally die within 4 weeks (31, 39). The 4L/PS/ mice survived for 34 weeks, and they were infertile. Only limited numbers of 4L/PS/ and 9H/PS-NA mice were obtained; thus, only limited analyses were performed.
Prosaposin transgene expression Transgenic saposin proteins in PS-NA mice were analyzed by immunoblots and scored relative to the levels of saposins in WT mice using goat anti-mouse prosaposin antiserum. This antibody reacts with prosaposin and all four saposins (A, B, C, and D). To correct for variations in the application amounts, the saposin levels were normalized to ß-actin level on each gel. The amounts of transgenic saposin protein levels varied with the tissue source and were 445% of WT levels (Fig. 1A) . These levels were consistent in the specific tissue and did not vary significantly within or among the various mouse strains.
After metabolic labeling, the secretion of transgenic prosaposin was assessed by immunoprecipitations of cell culture media using rabbit anti-mouse saposin D antibody. Transgenic prosaposin was detected in medium from cultured fibroblasts, hippocampal neurons, and hepatocytes of PS-NA mice (Fig. 1B). The transgenic prosaposin was secreted at a lower level than in comparable samples from WT mice. This was evaluated because exon 8, which encodes the amino acids QDQ in the prosaposin gene, has been proposed to be a secretion signal (14, 40) and the prosaposin transgene in PS-NA mice does not contain exon 8. Thus, these results demonstrate that the prosaposin transgene produces a prosaposin protein that is processed into saposins and is also secreted intact in relative proportion to its expression levels in whole tissue extracts (compare Fig. 1A, B).
Visceral tissues
CNS No gross CNS malformations were found in any of the mice examined in these studies. Throughout their lives ( 2 years), V394L/V394L and D409H/D409H did not have any brain pathology, nor did they exhibit neurological abnormalities (8). PS-NA mice developed a neurological phenotype by 3 months (31). The neuropathology of 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice was very similar to that of PS-NA mice (31). The 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice appeared phenotypically normal until 10 weeks and then developed a slowly progressing CNS phenotype that included gait ataxia, generalized tremor, gross shaking to the point of falling over, and a neurogenic bladder. Lack of rear limb control was the first manifestation. This progressed to almost complete paralysis of the rear limbs by 20 weeks. The lack of body control eventually resulted in the inability to eat and drink, with consequent malnutrition, dehydration, and demise of these mice ( 22 weeks). The neurological phenotype in 4L/PS/ mice was indistinguishable from that of PS/ mice (31). Similar to PS-NA mice (31), the neurons of dorsal root ganglia were filled with storage material in 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice. The degenerated neurons in the cerebral cortex and loss of Purkinje cells in the cerebellum were found in such mice >10 weeks old. By electron microcopy, little storage material was seen in Purkinje cells of PS-NA and 4L/PS-NA mice (Fig. 5A)
. Interestingly, the granule cells of 4L/PS-NA mice had large numbers of inclusions at 10 weeks, but very few granule cells contained the inclusions in PS-NA mice at 17.5 weeks (Fig. 5B).
Lipid analyses The lipid analyses of 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice showed that the major additional lipid accumulated in these mice compared with PS-NA mice was GC (Fig. 6A) . At 20 weeks, GC was 3- to 10-fold increased in 4L/PS-NA compared with PS-NA mice. GC progressively accumulated from 4 to 20 weeks in livers, spleens, and lungs of 4L/PS-NA mice (Fig. 6B). Small amounts of GC accumulated in age-matched GCase point-mutated (V394L/V394L and D409H/D409H) mouse tissues (8). Predominant lactosylceramide (LacCer) accumulation and slightly increased GC were reported previously in PS-NA and PS/ mouse tissues (31, 39). In 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice, LacCer was only slightly increased in visceral tissues. These data indicated that the combined deficiency of saposins with GCase point mutations (V394L or D409H) in 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice led to a predominant increase in GC accumulation.
GCase activity and stability The residual GCase in vitro activity in V394L/V394L mice was 510% of WT levels. PS-NA mice showed reduced GCase activity in visceral tissues by 3060% (24). Compared with V394L/V394L mice, the GCase activity in 4L/PS-NA mice was decreased significantly in liver (P = 0.0013), spleen (P = 0.0007), and fibroblasts (P = 0.0021) but not in lung and cerebrum (Fig. 7A)
. For 9H/PS-NA, no difference in GCase activity was detectable relative to D409H/D409H mice; this was likely attributable to the variance in measured activity being within the noise level of the error of repeated measures in these assays (data not shown). Strains (C57BL/6J, 129SvEvBrd, or FVB) and mixes of these strains were tested for WT GCase activity. All were found to have equivalent GCase activities (data not shown).
To assess the GCase protein level, fibroblast lysates from WT, PS-NA, 4L/PS-NA, and V394L/V394L mice were analyzed by Western blot analysis using rabbit anti-mouse GCase antibody (Fig. 7B). Relative to WT tissues, the GCase protein level was reduced by 60% in V394L/V394L fibroblasts and by 90% in 4L/PS-NA fibroblasts. These results imply that the stability of the mutant enzyme was further reduced in the background of a subnormal level of saposins in fibroblasts (24). This lower GCase activity and protein reduced the mutant GCase to a level below which GC accumulated in excess.
There have been several attempts to create animal models of Gaucher disease for pathogenic and therapeutic studies (6, 7, 42). An ideal model would closely mimic the human disease and rapidly accumulate the substrate GC in Gaucher cells. The null mouse and those created by insertional mutagenesis have been lethal early in life, attributable in part to a skin permeability barrier defect (6, 7). Mice with point mutations at the gba locus have exhibited phenotypes ranging from near phenotypic normalcy to biochemical and histological changes similar to the human disease (68). Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation of GCase-null cells into WT mice was tested because of the predominant involvement of the macrophage line in human Gaucher disease (42). This resulted in minor abnormalities. Here, a variant of GC storage disease was developed that provides an analog to human Gaucher disease, with characteristic visceral histopathology and biochemical abnormalities. In particular, the homozygous GCase point-mutated mice (V394L, D409H, and D409V) were viable, with low residual activities in all cells but with few storage cells and variable levels of GC accumulation (8). To develop viable, but more severe, models, two genetically modified mice were created based on the known stability effects of saposin C on GCase (24). Because V394L and D409H GCases have abnormal kinetics and stability, we reasoned that partial deficiencies of prosaposin (PS-NA) combined with such point mutations of GCase would further reduce GCase levels in visceral and CNS tissues. We postulated that this GCase level would be below the threshold needed to manifest GC storage. The resultant mice had obvious GC storage primarily in macrophages of visceral organs, and the morphology of the resultant storage cells resembled Gaucher disease cells in the human. However, unlike the human disease, splenic and liver sizes were nearly normal. The CNS clinical course and histopathology resembled those of the PS-NA mice, but with increased accumulation of GC. The 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice were essentially identical, implying that a "floor" of residual activity had been reached, which was consistent with survival without obvious skin abnormalities. Interestingly, attempts to create a D409V/D409V;PS-NA mouse did not result in any live pups with that genotype from >200 pups. The mechanism by which these mice were created relates primarily to the effects and interactions of saposin C or saposins with the mutant GCases. Theoretically, the lower amounts of saposins produced in the PS-NA mouse would alter WT and mutant enzyme stabilities and activities, as shown in (Fig. 7) and previously demonstrated to be attributable to a proteolytic effect of saposin C (24). Similarly, the residual activity of the various mutant GCases, particularly V394L, was differentially affected and varied closely with the level of prosaposin expressed in various tissues. For example, in liver and spleen, statistically different levels of residual V394L GCase activities were present, and these were in the tissues with the lowest level of expression of saposins. In comparison, lung and brain had 310 times higher levels of expression of saposins from the transgene than did liver and spleen. The residual V394L activities in lung and brain were not distinguishable in the 4L/PS-NA or V394L homozygote mice. No difference was found with the D409H mouse homozygotes (because of limited samples) compared with their 9H/PS-NA variants. Obviously, there were detectable differences at a physiological level between the residual activity in each tissue, because GCase in both liver and spleen was decreased significantly compared with the respective levels in lung and brain. Indeed, the progressive GC accumulation in liver, spleen, lung, and cerebellum increased with age and reached levels that were 310 times those in the respective age-matched PS-NA mouse tissues. Thus, although a detectable change with the in vitro assay for V394L or D409H activity could not be appreciated, this is evident at a pathophysiological level. Indeed, in fibroblasts from the 4L/PS-NA mice, the GCase protein was decreased substantially compared with that from the V394L homozygotes. This was consistent with the findings in liver and spleen and indicated a stability effect of saposins (especially saposin C) on GCase. Previously, mouse models based on the point mutations V394L and D409H had been bred into the null mouse background to decrease the level of activity of GCase, at least theoretically, in the respective homozygotes by 50% (i.e., V394L/null and D409H/null would have 50% of the residual activity of the respective homozygotes). Such mice did show progressive accumulations of Gaucher cells and GC in some visceral tissues of advanced age mice (8). The most progressive phenotype developed was based on the D409V/null mouse, which exhibited substantial visceral GC and Gaucher cell accumulation, particularly in spleen and lungs. However, age match comparisons between 4L/PS-NA and 9H/PS-NA mice and V394L/null and D409H/null mice showed much more significant accumulation of Gaucher cells and GC in the present mice with PS-NA. This suggests that the theoretical 50% decrease obtained with a null heteroallele was still above the threshold reached in these current mice to produce significant GC and Gaucher cell accumulation in the various tissues. Of particular interest was the lack of GC accumulation in the brains of the respective heteroallelic homozygotes with the null mice compared with the models developed here, which have substantial additional accumulation of GC compared with PS-NA mice. These results and the fact that we were unable to produce the 9V/PS-NA mice indicate that the models developed here were near a threshold for survivability and manifestations of Gaucher disease in the mouse. An interesting finding in 4L/PS-NA mice was the large number of storage inclusions in granule cells of cerebellum. These are present only very occasionally in PS-NA mice. It is not clear why the granule cells were more vulnerable to GC accumulation. This result supports a cell type-specific threshold for substrate flux. Because of the disruption of glycosphingolipid metabolism in PS-NA mice, one might anticipate an altered flux of glycosphingolipid precursors through the pathways to GC. Indeed, the original intent of the present models was based on the presumption that either the V394L or D409H homozygote would provide a Gaucher disease phenotype in the mouse. The original cross-breeding into PS-NA mice assumed that a decreased flow of substrate (i.e., substrate depletion) through the glycosphingolipid degradative pathway would result in an alleviation of any phenotype. However, the discovery of the proteolytic stabilities and protective effects of saposin C toward GCase negated that presumption. In addition, other than GC, only LacCer was slightly increased. Thus, at least in visceral tissues, the accumulation of GC from hematologic cells appears to proceed unimpeded and leads to no significant abnormalities other than those detected in PS-NA mice initially. Therefore, the mice produced here appear to primarily manifest additional abnormalities related to GCase and not to other parts of the glycosphingolipid pathway. The progressive accumulation of GC in various tissues, as well as the progressive Gaucher cell infiltrating in these tissues, provide interesting pathogenetic and, potentially, therapeutic models to evaluate these processes in a mouse model. The development of a variety of therapeutic approaches based on enzyme supplementation, substrate depletion, and gene therapy could be evaluated in such models for effectiveness across the spectrum of involved tissues. However, the models are not homologous, but analogous, to human Gaucher disease, because combined hypomorphism for GCase and prosaposin has not been described in humans. Thus, these models could provide proof of principle, rather than direct transference, for the human Gaucher disease types. These models also provide some insight into the potential interaction of hypomorphic states within a particular pathway leading to exaggerated disease phenotypes. One might anticipate that therapies based on enzymes, supplementation, or gene therapy might have lesser effects in the PS-NA background because saposin C would be limiting. Preliminary studies with mice containing a tetracycline transactivator-controlled human GCase with liver expression suggest that substantial therapeutic effects of "endogenous enzyme replacement" can be achieved in the background of the PS-NA mouse (unpublished data). In addition, these mouse models could provide an interesting platform to evaluate substrate depletion approaches to Gaucher disease, because GC accumulates substantially in all tissues and, particularly, in the brain. An advantage of these mouse models for substrate depletion evaluation is that CNS and other glycosphingolipids are involved as a result of the PS-NA abnormalities, and the total effect of such approaches could be evaluated in these mice. Finally, one might consider the use of molecular chaperones for the enhancement of endogenous mutant GCase activity in these mice and evaluate the tissue-specific effects. Indeed, we have shown that the V394L mutant enzyme in mouse fibroblasts shows a 4- to 7-fold enhancement of residual enzyme activity when exposed to derivatives of N-alkyl-deoxynojirimycins at subtoxic levels (unpublished data). This suggests not only a potential for in vivo effects that could be evaluated in the current mouse models but also a potential "mutation-specific effect" that might show greater enhancement relative to some other mutations in the GCase gene.
The authors thank Dr. Keith Stringer for scientific input on the immunohistochemistry study, Humin Ran, Matt Zamzow, Rachel Reboulet, and Andrzej Kazimierczuk for their technical assistance, Lisa McMillin, Meredith Farmer, and Chris Woods for skilled tissue preparation and photomicrographs, and Fannie Anderson for her clerical expertise. This work was supported by grants to G.A.G. from the National Institutes of Health (RO1 NS/DK-36681 and DK-36729). Manuscript received May 19, 2005 and in revised form July 15, 2005.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||